Health Promotion Challenges and Solutions CA Sample Answer: Evaluating Irish Primary Schools as a Setting (DkIT)
For information and reference only – not to be submitted as your own work.
This is an abridged model-answer extract for the DkIT Health Promotion Challenges and Solutions continuous assessment: a 2,500-word critical evaluation of one health promotion setting. The full brief is on the live question page, and our guide to how to approach this health promotion essay explains what markers look for. The extract below chooses one setting (Irish primary schools), one issue (physical inactivity in children) and follows the structure the brief suggests: introduction, critical evaluation, recommendations, conclusion. It uses DkIT Harvard in-text citations. Pick your own setting and issue for your submission.
Planning table
| Marking area (from the brief) | What this extract does | Approx. words in full essay |
|---|---|---|
| Understanding of the campaign and its context | Defines the setting, population and issue; places them in Healthy Ireland policy | 400 |
| Application and justification of approach and model(s) | Settings approach, Ottawa Charter action areas, RE-AIM as the evaluation lens | 350 |
| Depth and quality of critical evaluation | Active School Flag and the wider Health Promoting School evidence, judged on reach, effect, adoption, implementation and maintenance | 1,100 |
| Supporting evidence and referencing | Peer-reviewed studies and official Irish policy, cited in text | Throughout |
| Recommendations | Three evidence-based, setting-specific actions | 450 |
| Conclusion and structure | Short, evaluative, no new evidence | 200 |
Introduction
Physical inactivity in childhood is a public health issue because habits formed at school age tend to carry into later life, and because inactivity is linked with weight gain and poorer wellbeing. This essay evaluates how well the Irish primary school, as a health promotion setting, has promoted physical activity among children aged roughly four to twelve. It focuses on the Active School Flag (ASF), a national whole-school initiative, and places it within the wider Health Promoting School (HPS) approach.
Ireland’s overarching policy is Healthy Ireland, which sets out a framework for improved health and wellbeing to 2025 with four goals: increase the proportion of people who are healthy at all stages of life, reduce health inequalities, protect the public from threats to health and wellbeing, and create an environment where every individual and sector of society can play their part (Department of Health, 2013). The Healthy Ireland Strategic Action Plan 2021–2025 describes itself as a cross-government, cross-sectoral plan with actions assigned to lead departments (Department of Health, 2021). Schools are one of the sectors through which these goals are expected to be delivered.
The essay argues that the ASF shows real strength in reach and adoption but that the evidence of effect is thin, and that equity and sustainability are the weakest points. It uses the settings approach and the Ottawa Charter to explain why schools are chosen, and RE-AIM to judge how well the initiative has worked.
Theoretical approach and justification
The settings approach and the Ottawa Charter
The Ottawa Charter states that health is created and lived by people within the settings of their everyday life, where they learn, work, play and love (World Health Organization, 1986). It names five action areas: build healthy public policy, create supportive environments, strengthen community action, develop personal skills and reorient health services (World Health Organization, 1986). A school is a setting in this sense because it reaches almost every child for several hours a day, and because it can act on the environment (playground, timetable, policy) as well as on individual skills.
The Irish framework for primary schools defines school health promotion as any activity undertaken to improve and/or protect the health of all school users, which is wider than health education, and it organises the work around school policy, curriculum and learning, partnerships, and the physical and social environment (Health Service Executive, 2013). This matches the Ottawa Charter action areas closely: policy maps to healthy public policy, environment to supportive environments, partnerships to community action, and curriculum to personal skills.
A settings approach has a known weakness. Dooris (2006) argues that evaluating healthy settings is difficult because they are complex, long-term and shaped by context, so conventional trial designs often fit them poorly. That caution applies throughout this essay: an absence of strong trial evidence does not prove an initiative does not work, but it does limit what can be claimed.
RE-AIM as the evaluation lens
RE-AIM judges the public health impact of an intervention on five dimensions: reach, effectiveness, adoption, implementation and maintenance (Glasgow, Vogt and Boles, 1999). It is useful here for two reasons. First, it stops an essay from reporting only whether an intervention “worked” in a small study. Second, it makes the equity question visible, because reach and adoption can be compared across more and less advantaged schools. The remainder of the evaluation is organised around these dimensions.
Critical evaluation
Reach and adoption
The ASF is a national, school-based physical activity initiative operating at scale. Belton et al. (2020), reviewing ten years of the programme, report that about 85% of Irish primary schools have registered with it at some point and that 1,419 schools, roughly 46%, have earned at least one flag. On reach and adoption, those are substantial figures.
Two cautions apply. Registering is not the same as completing the process, and the gap between 85% registered and 46% awarded suggests that many schools start but do not finish. Belton et al. (2020) also note that schools cite time commitments and paperwork as disincentives, and that some aspects are harder for socially disadvantaged schools to implement. If the schools that struggle are those serving the children with the greatest need, the initiative may widen rather than narrow inequalities, which would cut across the second goal of Healthy Ireland (Department of Health, 2013).
The wider HPS picture is less encouraging. Moynihan, Jourdan and Mannix McNamara (2016) surveyed all 704 post-primary schools in Ireland and received 394 responses (56%). Just over half of responding schools described themselves as health promoting, but progress was strongest in environment and curriculum, while partnerships and policy and planning needed more attention. Among schools that identified as health promoting, only about 35% had a team supporting development and 36% had a supporting policy. Many schools understood health promotion mainly as diet, exercise and curriculum rather than as a whole-school approach. This study covers post-primary schools, so it cannot be applied directly to primary level, but it shows that adopting the language of health promotion and delivering a whole-school approach are different things. Its self-reported data are a further limitation.
Effectiveness
The best Irish evidence on effect is limited. Belton et al. (2020) report a pilot in three DEIS primary schools (126 children in third and fifth class and 39 teachers) with no control group. In-school moderate-to-vigorous physical activity rose in all three schools by 12-month follow-up, and the rise was larger in the two schools that met all the programme’s success criteria. The third school met 46% of the criteria and did not receive a flag. Motivation, self-efficacy, school affect and peer support did not change significantly, although teachers reported better classroom behaviour.
This is encouraging but weak evidence. With three schools and no comparison group, the result may reflect other changes in the schools, and the measure covers in-school activity only, not whole-day activity. The finding that fuller implementation was associated with larger gains is the most useful point for practice. The absence of change in motivation and self-efficacy suggests the programme changes the environment more than it changes how children feel about being active, which raises a question over whether the behaviour would continue outside the school.
The international evidence puts this in context. Langford et al. (2014), in a Cochrane review of 67 cluster-randomised trials covering 1,345 schools, found that the HPS framework produced improvements in physical activity, physical fitness, fruit and vegetable intake, tobacco use and being bullied, and some improvement in body mass index. They found no evidence of effect on fat intake, alcohol use, drug use, mental health, violence or bullying others. The quality of evidence was low to moderate, because of self-reported outcomes, high attrition and little long-term follow-up (Langford et al., 2014). The Irish ASF evidence therefore points the same way as the international picture on physical activity, but with far less certainty.
Implementation and maintenance
Implementation depends on school capacity and system support. Belton et al. (2020) describe a renewal process in which schools re-apply for the flag, and about 34% of currently engaged schools are renewal schools. This is a sign of maintenance, although a flag-based award can reward visible activity over embedded change.
The policy environment adds both support and pressure. The Wellbeing Policy Statement and Framework for Practice 2018–2023 positions wellbeing as a whole-school responsibility and expects every school to embed a self-evaluation wellbeing promotion process by 2023 (Department of Education and Skills, 2018). This gives physical activity work a natural home in school planning. The risk, as the findings of Moynihan, Jourdan and Mannix McNamara (2016) suggest, is that without a team and a written policy in each school, a national expectation can remain a statement rather than a practice.
Summary against RE-AIM
| Dimension | Evidence | Judgement |
|---|---|---|
| Reach | About 85% of primary schools registered (Belton et al., 2020) | Strong, but equity of reach untested |
| Effectiveness | Three-school pilot, no control; Cochrane review supports HPS for physical activity (Langford et al., 2014) | Promising, low certainty |
| Adoption | 1,419 schools (about 46%) with at least one flag (Belton et al., 2020) | Good; gap between registering and completing |
| Implementation | Full criteria met in two of three pilot schools; time and paperwork cited as barriers | Variable, linked to school capacity |
| Maintenance | Renewal process; about 34% of engaged schools are renewals (Belton et al., 2020) | Some evidence; long-term effect unknown |
Recommendations
- Target support at schools that start but do not finish. Because 85% of schools have registered but about 46% have earned a flag, targeted mentoring and reduced paperwork for DEIS and under-resourced schools would address the barriers reported by Belton et al. (2020) and would serve the equity goal of Healthy Ireland (Department of Health, 2013).
- Build a team and a written policy in every school. The survey by Moynihan, Jourdan and Mannix McNamara (2016) found weak partnerships and policy, so the ASF should be tied to the school’s wellbeing self-evaluation process (Department of Education and Skills, 2018) and to the policy and partnership strands of the national framework (Health Service Executive, 2013).
- Commission a stronger evaluation. A controlled study with more schools, whole-day activity measures and follow-up beyond 12 months would answer the effectiveness and maintenance questions that Belton et al. (2020) and Langford et al. (2014) leave open, in line with Dooris’s (2006) call for evaluation designs suited to settings.
Conclusion
The Irish primary school is a strong setting for promoting physical activity because it offers reach, a national policy framework and a recognisable award in the ASF. Judged by RE-AIM, the initiative is strongest on reach and adoption and weakest on proven effect, equity and long-term maintenance. The recommendations focus on those weaknesses: support for schools that struggle, a team and policy in each school, and a better evaluation. The wider lesson is that a settings approach succeeds when the whole school changes, not when a single programme is added to it.
Where to go next
If you are choosing a setting for your own essay, our nursing and healthcare assignment help page explains how support for health-related coursework works, and essay help covers structure and argument for longer pieces. For another DkIT health brief, see the NURS N8284 respiratory case study question and its reference sample. When you have your own brief, you can submit it for a free quote.
References
Belton, S., Britton, Ú., Murtagh, E., Meegan, S., Duff, C. and McGann, J. (2020) ‘Ten years of “flying the flag”: an overview and retrospective consideration of the Active School Flag physical activity initiative for children – design, development and evaluation’, Children, 7(12), article 300. doi: 10.3390/children7120300.
Department of Education and Skills (2018) Wellbeing policy statement and framework for practice 2018–2023. Dublin: Department of Education and Skills.
Department of Health (2013) Healthy Ireland: a framework for improved health and wellbeing 2013–2025. Dublin: Department of Health.
Department of Health (2021) Healthy Ireland strategic action plan 2021–2025. Dublin: Department of Health.
Dooris, M. (2006) ‘Healthy settings: challenges to generating evidence of effectiveness’, Health Promotion International, 21(1), pp. 55–65. doi: 10.1093/heapro/dai030.
Glasgow, R.E., Vogt, T.M. and Boles, S.M. (1999) ‘Evaluating the public health impact of health promotion interventions: the RE-AIM framework’, American Journal of Public Health, 89(9), pp. 1322–1327.
Health Service Executive (2013) Schools for Health in Ireland: framework for developing a health promoting school – primary. Dublin: Health Service Executive.
Langford, R., Bonell, C.P., Jones, H.E., Pouliou, T., Murphy, S.M., Waters, E., Komro, K.A., Gibbs, L.F., Magnus, D. and Campbell, R. (2014) ‘The WHO Health Promoting School framework for improving the health and well-being of students and their academic achievement’, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2014(4), CD008958. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD008958.pub2.
Moynihan, S., Jourdan, D. and Mannix McNamara, P. (2016) ‘An examination of Health Promoting Schools in Ireland’, Health Education, 116(1), pp. 16–33. doi: 10.1108/HE-03-2014-0045.
World Health Organization (1986) Ottawa charter for health promotion. Geneva: World Health Organization.

Prepared by
Ireland Assignment Helper Editorial Team
This model answer was prepared by our editorial team in response to a real assignment brief we received. It shows one way to approach the task and is meant as a study guide, not for submission.